Visit our Business Solutions website >>

Mafia for Windows

Mafia for Windows
alaScore 72

95 reviews

Feb, 2018

alaTest has collected and analyzed 95 reviews of Mafia for Windows. The average rating for this product is 4.2/5, compared to an average rating of 3.9/5 for other PC Games for all reviews.

We analyzed user and expert ratings, product age and more factors. Compared to other PC Games the Mafia for Windows is awarded an overall alaScore™ of 72/100 = Good quality.

Review analysis

(Based on 95 reviews)

User Reviews  


Below is a list of reviews for this or similar products. If you think this grouping is wrong please click here to flag.
Read more on our FAQ’s page.
Showing 1 - 10 of 95 Show Reviews: in English

Consumer review by: boothegoose (

Welcome to the family


Mafia is effectively GTA set in 1920's America during the time of the Prohibition, with a much more mature and well-developed plot, and features a multitude of painstakingly recreated cars and vehicles from that historical era, and the attention to...

Rich and diverse plot, cool music, decent graphics

Driving and steering is awkward

May, 2006

Consumer review by: underdawg (

Mafia-Calling It A GTA Clone Doesn't Do It Justice


It is impossible to write a review of Mafia without comparing it to the Grand Theft Auto Series. Just so you know. Like GTA, it is in essence a third-person shooter and you also drive a lot. Your character, Tommy Angelo, is a member of the Mafia and...

Nice storyline. Violent

Can be frustratingly hard. Cops

Mar, 2005

Consumer review by: fick13 (

Accurate? Maybe. Fun? Oh yeah.


My view of this game may be slanted, given that I played it when my PC was on the fritz and I didn't have sound, so as far as voice acting and soundtrack, I have nothing to say.

Vivid gameplay, capturing storyline, Stunning Realism

Stunning Realism, lack of in-game freedom, the dang thing's huge

Feb, 2005

Consumer review by: Leon (

Mafia for Windows


I really hate to say that this game is quite mediocre since it does have a few things going for it, such as the gorgeous graphics and somewhat interesting storyline. However, I cannot recommend Mafia to anyone who has already played a truly great...

Dec, 2004

Consumer review by: euroman1970 (

MAFIA - a must have game


After about 6 months of deliberating I finally purchased this game for $9.99 (from Right from the beginning I was completely intrigued by the storyline, cars, characters, and graphics of this game. Opening credits, music, are an A+. You...

Excellent storyline, good graphics, intense shootouts, lifelike characters

No save button, graphics sometimes choppy, some levels get frustrating after a while

Mar, 2004

Consumer review by: jeffvc (

Mafia for Windows


I went back and forth on this game. When it first came out, I was in the middle of Grand Theft Auto, and I thought, Mafia looks very cool. I read the reviews, which were mixed. And I can see why. My opinion is very mixed. Like a lot of other people, I...

Feb, 2004

Consumer review by: Aku (

Mafia for Windows


Mafia takes place in the fictional city of Lost Heaven, which is a good name for the place because Mafia is a slice of gaming heaven. This offering from what is fast becoming my favorite game maker - Illusion Softworks (creators of Hidden and Dangerous...

Sep, 2003

Consumer review by: Dennis (

Mafia for Windows


I really wanted to like this game. I love the era and the concept in general. The game catches the ambience of the era very well and the voice acting and character models are excellent as well as the vehicles. THe problem I have is the missions. They...

Aug, 2003

Consumer review by: Jose Rivera (

Mafia for Windows


Over all this Game was and always will be a Blast!!..Keep in mind that the developers of this game intentionaly made Cars slow and bulky this is the 1930's Duuhh!! no super charged cars here..untill after you play it all the way to the end.. WHAT'S...

Aug, 2003

Consumer review by: bob (

Mafia for Windows


When I play mafia I find myself asking, why do I play computer games? The Answer for me is to have a fun diversion from everyday life. Mafia, whilst beautifully crafted with excellent graphics and great voice acting and music totaly fails in the fun...

Aug, 2003