Visit our Business Solutions website >>

Brother MFC-J5910DW

alaTest has collected and analyzed 2588 reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW. The average rating for this product is 4.1/5, compared to an average rating of 3.9/5 for other Printers for all reviews. Comments about the design and size are generally positive. The usability and price also get good views, whereas some have doubts about the durability and noise.

performance, price, usability, size, design

reliability, noise, durability

We analyzed user and expert ratings, product age and more factors. Compared to other Printers the Brother MFC-J5910DW is awarded an overall alaScore™ of 88/100 = Very good quality.

Review analysis

(Based on 2588 reviews)

Expert Reviews  

User Reviews  

Showing 490 review(s)

Expert Reviews User Reviews
Showing 1 - 465 of 490 Show Reviews: in English | in other languages (2098)

Consumer review by: ( review summary for Brother MFC-J5910DW


alaTest has collected and analyzed 198 user reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW from The average user rating for this product is 3.6/5, compared to an average user rating of 3.9/5 for other Printers on Reviewers are impressed by the paper handling and print quality. The performance and usability also get good views. There are some mixed reviews about the design. The noise and durability get negative opinions.

price, usability, performance, print quality, paper handling

reliability, size, durability, noise

71% of the reviews on give this product a positive rating.

This summary is based on the products: Brother MFCJ5910DW A3 Colour Inkjet Multifunction Printer (Print/Scan/Copy/Fax)Brother MFCJ5910DW A3 Colour Inkjet Multifunction Printer (Print/Scan/Copy/Fax)Brother MFC J 5910 DW Colour Multifunctional Printer

Aug, 2015

Consumer review by: ( review summary for Brother MFC-J5910DW


alaTest has collected and analyzed 257 user reviews of Brother MFC-J5910DW from The average user rating for this product is 3.7/5, compared to an average user rating of 3.6/5 for other Printers on Views about the print quality and size are overall positive. The performance and price also get good views. Views are divided on the noise, and many are negative about the reliability.

usability, price, performance, size, print quality


76% of the reviews on give this product a positive rating.

This summary is based on the products: Brother Mfcj5910Dw/J6510Dw/J6710Dw/J6910Dw Super High Yield Yellow Ink (1200 Yield)Brother Printer MFC-J5910DW Wireless Color Photo Printer with Scanner, Copier and FaxBrother MFC-9125cn Digital Color All-in-One with Fax and Networking

Aug, 2015

Expert review by: (

Brother MFC-J5910DW


The key difference between the MFC-J5910DW and the Brother MFC-J6510DW is the paper size they can scan. The MFC-J5910DW is limited to scanning up to legal size, rather than tabloid size. The smaller flatbed lets the printer itself be smaller, at 10.2...

Prints at up to tabloid size (11 by 17 inches). Scans, copies, and faxes. Automatic document feeder. Duplex printing

Only one paper tray, so you can't keep letter and tabloid size paper loaded at the same time

The Brother MFC-J5910DW prints at tabloid size, scans and faxes even over a network, works as a standalone copier and fax machine, and is both cheap to buy and cheap to run.



Expert review by: William Harrel (

Brother MFC-J5910DW


Some makers of all-in-one (AIO) inkjet printers excel in certain niches. Canon, for example, makes great photo-centric AIOs. Brother, on the other hand, engineers great business-centric models that provide many of the productivity and convenience...

Prints oversize sheets up to 11x17 inches ; Relatively low cost of ink ; Good-looking business-document output

Poor photograph printing and copying ; Scan and copy times slightly slower than average ; Small LCD

The MFC-J5910DW prints ledger-size (11x17-inch) pages for a great price, and it prints good-looking business documents. It struggles, however, when printing and copying photographs.

Feb, 2012

Expert review by: Francis D'sa (

Brother MFC-J5910DW Review


Printers are a need for every office and an all-in-one functionality printer is preferred because it offers space and power saving features. Brother International has been in the market for a long time now and offers a range of printers varying from...

The printer has a monthly duty cycle of 7,000 pages. Consumables packaged with the product are four starter cartridges, which can yield around 600 pages. Each cartridge costs around Rs. 435, which calculates the print economy to be at Rs 0.70 for B/W...

Nov, 2012

Expert review by: Simon Handby (

Brother MFC-J5910DW review


This fast, generally competent MFP is good value. Be aware, however, that while it can print to A3, it can only scan, fax or copy up to A4

Mar, 2012

Expert review by: Trusted Reviews (

Brother MFC-J5910DW


Brother's MFC-J5910 is a duplex, wireless all-in-one with added A3 print. All this for £125 should be a good deal, right?

Duplex A3 print, Programmable functions, Flexible feature-set for money

Below average print quality, Awkward and flimsy paper tray, Looks like a tank

Jan, 2012

Expert review by: Martyn Clayden (

Brother MFC-J5910DW Printer review


Brother's new budget-conscious A3 MFP dips on quality. They say bigger isn't necessarily better but when it comes...

Economic A3 printing as part of a multifunction package

Print colours appear rather pale and lifeless

The Brother MFC-J5910DW is a sturdy multifunction printer that includes fax capability, good connectivity options and A3 sized printing (but not copying). This is together with excellent controls, however, it's let down by average quality printing and...

Jan, 2012

Consumer review by: N/A (



Wireless network setup was easy and I've never had to reboot for connectivity - like most wifi printers.

Great printer all around. Decent photographs. SUPER cheap ink! The high yield black gets 2500 pages! That is the most I'd ever seen for an inkjet

Photos could be a bit better, though they are totally decent

Mar, 2014

Consumer review by: N/A (

Dependable, multifunction and wireless!


Epson printer just up and died on me and I had some NewEgg gift cards so I picked up this little honey. Set up was easy and straight forward, no issues getting it working wirelessly. LCD display is so intuitive to use, makes for job setup and running...

Front loading and discharge makes placing it against wall or in cabinet easy to use. Document feeder is excellent, smooth loading and makes for quick batch work, Scanner works fantastic, no shadowing or over exposure. Compact size is nice for small...

Tends to go through ink pretty quickly, depending on tasks, can be loud when first starting printing or copying, also high quality printing can generate loud whine from printhead dispensing ink

Oct, 2013

Consumer review by: Sharon (

Not impressed


Great scanner. High speed copier

Colors appear washed out. Too many steps to get colors right. Paper jams too often. Could not clear error without removing power from the device. No manual feed. Have to remove all paper to print 1 envelope

May, 2013

Consumer review by: msgtopom (

Great Printer


Went a little crazy trying to install this but when all else failled called tech support they had a fix for the "Verizon" issue took less than 15 min. Tech support was very professional and hooked me up. Highly recomend this printer ease of use...

Great print quality works well with all devices ease of use. Great tech support. Brother app for phone works real good

This printer has issues with Verizon Fios routters they will not comunicate with each other. But on the good side called tech support they have an easy fix for this problem took about 15 mins. Printer was up and running

Jun, 2012