A worthy successor to the original?

Brilliant multiplayer, Spec Ops mode

Is this one just for the fans?

Fantastic and beautiful videogame recreation of the biggest band in the world

Another season rolls in

Loads the new interface makes it easier to glide around the many parts of the game, while the matches themselves feel more fluid, thanks to the touchline shouts. The backroom advice offered by your staff is a neat addition, plus the tactical ...

Will this be Sony's big Christmas hit?

Incredible aesthetics, total non-stop action, keeps you thoroughly hooked

Semper fidalis?

True sandbox game, looks pretty good, variety in missions

One for the discerning viewer?

Deft and imaginative storytelling that weaves a remarkable tale of incredible richness

Halo without the Chief

Firefight mode is brilliant, great storyline, same old Halo FPS action

No Firefight random play, can be too slow-paced

The series continues with a brilliant single player campaign, and tonnes of multiplayer options

Can this match Football Manager?

Fast paced, excellent scouting system

Terrible UI, still not realistic enough, poor on-pitch action

Getting closer, but still a while to go before it can rival the great Football Manager series

The best football title ever?

New Virtual Pro options, plays an excellent game of football, so many little touches

The start of a new era in rhythm rocking?

Wide-ranging setlist, loads of new multiplayer modes, DS compatibility for Wii owners, Party Play and Mii Freestyle are excellent additions, far more approachable to casual users

Instrument calibration is awkward

Activision has really pushed the boat out with Guitar Hero 5, creating the most approachable and enthralling rhythm-rocking game to date