Visit our Business Solutions website >>

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition (Xbox 360)

alaTest has collected and analyzed 33 reviews of The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition (Xbox 360). The average rating for this product is 4.2/5, compared to an average rating of 3.9/5 for other Xbox 360 Games for all reviews. Views about the usability and price are generally positive. The gameplay and graphics also get good feedback, but many are less positive about the controls.

story, graphics, gameplay, price, usability


We analyzed user and expert ratings, product age and more factors. Compared to other Xbox 360 Games the The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition (Xbox 360) is awarded an overall alaScore™ of 86/100 = Very good quality.

Review analysis

(Based on 33 reviews)

Expert Reviews  

Showing 17 review(s)

Expert Reviews User Reviews


Below is a list of reviews for this or similar products. If you think this grouping is wrong please click here to flag.
Read more on our FAQ’s page.
Showing 1 - 10 of 17 Show Reviews: in English | in other languages (16)

Expert review by : Dante Kleinberg (

Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition, The


Ahoy there, fancy pants! If it's adventure ye be looking for, ye came to the right place. There's a reason that, nearly 20 years after its introduction, Monkey Island is arguably still the best known franchise in the adventure genre. For me, the...

Choice of playing original or enhanced versions at any time; wonderful voice acting; iconic score has been re-recorded with live instruments; new graphics can be quite winning; still very funny; great characters; puzzles are challenging but never unfair

New graphics won't appeal to everyone; can't mix and match upgraded features with the original game; optional gamepad controls are a bit of a chore

If you’re a long-time Monkey Island fan, it’s worth replaying the Special Edition for the addition of the voice cast alone. If you’ve never played the game before, it's an affordable and even more rewarding way to experience one of the greatest...

Sep, 2009

Expert review by : JGifford (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition Review [Xbox 360, PC]


Sometimes I feel privileged to live in the time I do. The wonders of the internet, not to mention food that I don't have to catch myself and indoor plumbing, make life far more enjoyable. Just like life, innovation in games takes place to increase...

Great, hilarious writing ; Enjoyable characters ; Beautiful new art style

Difficult puzzles with few tips ; Hint system helpful, not satisfying ; Dialogue skip is too broad

A remake of one of the classics. The cosmetic updates are great, the writing timeless, but the gameplay and design remains chained to the past.

Aug, 2009

Expert review by : Michael Black (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


Some great old game-types are making a come-back of late. Leading the charge are fighting and adventure games. The latter resurgence seems to revolve around LucasArts properties and Tell-tale, many of whom used to work at LucasArts.

Aug, 2009

Expert review by : OverlordStrider (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


A Brush with greatness

The Secret of Monkey Island returns in all its glory. You can even play the game with the original graphics

The sound effects could have been a bit sharper

With The Secret of Monkey Island – Special Edition, LucasArts has created an outstanding adventure game catering to both hardcore point and click fans, as well as those new to the genre. With easily mastered controls and an intuitive and streamlined...

Aug, 2009

Expert review by : Christopher Matulich (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


Since 1990, The Secret of Monkey Island has captivated many gamers through brilliance in writing and comedy, as well as an intuitive use of the point-and-click puzzle adventuring that has popularised the series and genre as a whole

For 10 dollars, The Secret of Monkey Island: SE is a steal. The game pays homage to series enthusiasts, as well as making it accessible to an entire new generation of gamers.

Jul, 2009

Expert review by : Brad Nicholson (

Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


Let's rewind to E3 2009. I'm inside LucasArts' conference room. I'm a few minutes early for the Star Wars: The Old Republic presentation. They have food and drink in both ...

Jul, 2009

Expert review by : Jim Cordeira (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


Drop that FPS, pack up your rubber chicken-with-a-pulley-in-the-middle, and book a trip back to Monkey Island.

For the uninitiated, the puzzles in Monkey Island are fairly logical even though a few require you to think humorously outside the box. There are of course a few points within the game that will likely strand a few new Monkey Island player for a little...

Jul, 2009

Expert review by : Rob Taylor (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


A less clunky interface gives this version the edge

Great writing and acting ; Fun puzzling ; Spiffy graphical update

Clunky new interface ; Unskippable dialogue ; World feels a bit empty

Not just a wonderfully realised slice of fan service, Monkey is also the perfect opportunity for those not around in 1990 to experience the sheer genius of insult swordfighting, to barter with Stan the used boat salesman, to insult Fester Shinetop, to...

Jul, 2009


Expert review by : Ryan Scott (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


So you want to be a pirate?

The classic game holds up; humor's still funny; revamped art style and interface work really well

Hint system doesn't always work; can't skip dialogue; voice underscores repetitiveness of conversations

Jul, 2009

Expert review by : Justin Calvert (

The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition


If you've got opposable thumbs, a sense of humor, and a brain that you're not afraid to use, this puzzle-filled adventure is one well worth taking.

Plenty of laugh-out-loud moments ; Inventive, satisfying puzzles ; New hint system lessens frustration ; Loads of well-written characters to interact with ; Look behind you, a three-headed monkey

No option to hear voice acting with original visuals ; Special Edition interface is a little clunky

Jul, 2009