Visit our Business Solutions website >>

HP 57/58 Tricolor and Photo Ink Cartridges Photo Value Pack (CR685AN#140)

HP 57/58 Tricolor and Photo Ink Cartridges Photo Value Pack (CR685AN#140)
alaScore 80

13 reviews

Feb, 2025

alaTest has collected and analyzed 13 reviews of HP 57/58 Tricolor and Photo Ink Cartridges Photo Value Pack (CR685AN#140). The average rating for this product is 4.4/5, compared to an average rating of 4.0/5 for other products in the same category for all reviews. Reviewers really like the usability. The price is also appreciated, but there are some critical opinions about the ink consumption.

price, usability

ink consumption

We analyzed user and expert ratings, product age and more factors. Compared to other products in the same category the HP 57/58 Tricolor and Photo Ink Cartridges Photo Value Pack (CR685AN#140) is awarded an overall alaScore™ of 80/100 = Very good quality.

Review analysis

(Based on 13 reviews)

User Reviews  

Review Ratings

  (46% of reviews)
Show all 5 star reviews   (46% of reviews)
Show all 4 star reviews   (8% of reviews)
Show all 3 star reviews   (no reviews)
    (no reviews)
 

Features

price
  Show positive (58%)Show negative (42%)(Show all)
ink consumption
  None yetShow negative (100%)(Show all)
usability
  Show positive (100%)None yet(Show all)

Showing 13 review(s)

Expert Reviews User Reviews

Disclaimer:

Below is a list of reviews for this or similar products. If you think this grouping is wrong please click here to flag.
Read more on our FAQ’s page.
Showing 1 - 10 of 13 Show Reviews: in English

Consumer review (staples.com)

I will buy the product again

 

We used to have to buy 57 and 58 separately. This pack saves us a lot of money.

Clean Replacement,Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace,Long Cartridge Life,Long Lasting Color,Sharp Tones & Colors

Jan, 2012
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

great value for both cartridges

 

I use my HP printer for numerous projects. From basic black and white to photos that are for decorative purposes. This "duo" pack provides consistent color, and is a great value. The yellow tends to fade with time.

Clean Replacement,Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace,Sharp Tones & Colors

Color Fades,Short Cartridge Life

Jan, 2012
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

HP INK

 

Good product that has short life and is very expensive. Would like a longer life at a fair cost.

Clean Replacement,Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace,Sharp Tones & Colors

Short Cartridge Life,Too Expensive

Jan, 2012
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

Great value

 

Good value, easy to use

Clean Replacement,Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace

Short Cartridge Life

Jan, 2012
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

Good value

 

none

Clean Replacement

Dec, 2011
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

love to print photos

 

I print a lot of photos and it is almost cheaper to go to a retail developer. I enjoy printing them at home on the fly if/when possible.

Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace,Long Cartridge Life

Too Expensive

Dec, 2011
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

HP Photo Ink

 

this two cartridge pack is set at a great price but since i print so many photos, the ink gets used up too quickly.....

Clean Replacement,Great price,Sharp Tones & Colors

Short Cartridge Life

Dec, 2011
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

Excellent Value of HP Photo Value Pack

 

Excellent ink quality not only for paper copies but for photos.

Clean Replacement,Dries Quickly,Easy to Replace,Long Cartridge Life,Long Lasting Color,Sharp Tones & Colors

Dec, 2011
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

Been buying this product for years

 

I have been using this product for many years as a photojournalist. All of my work has stood up. Colors remain vibrant. And my photos have met the standards of major publications worldwide.

Clean Replacement,Easy to Replace,Long Lasting Color,Sharp Tones & Colors,Vibrant colors

Dec, 2011
Read the full review

Consumer review (staples.com)

Good colors. Long lasting

 

I have been using this product for years and have never had a problem. I am a photojournalist and particular about my photos being the best. Have printed many hundreds of photos over the years.

Clean Replacement,Easy to Replace,Long Lasting Color,Sharp Tones & Colors

A bit expensive

Dec, 2011
Read the full review
1
2

Price comparison for HP 57/58 Tricolor and Photo Ink Cartridges Photo Value Pack (CR685AN#140)

No prices for this product